why didnt i like coraline? perhaps it was a bit too childish for me. that is strange given the general love i have for childlike wonder and amazement. the plot didnt pull me in the least. the visuals however, were fantastic and kept me watching albiet staring at the clock quite a bit. i probably would have appreciated this in the theaters quite a bit more especially with 3D. i think the problem was that there was nothing in the script for the adults. the message was pretty simple and clearly directed towards children. the main part directed towards adults was the macabre and gothic style stop motion. perhaps ive been spoiled by pixar who plant adult oriented material throughout the entire film.
why did i love the iron giant? it was really directed towards children but the obvious themes of warfare, mistrust, and preconceived prejudices (towards robots?) give it an adult sheen. i would say that this is sort of an anti-the day the earth stood still. alien robot comes to earth to pal around with humans. in both films, humans are the monsters AND other humans are the heroes but in the iron giant, the robot is the hero. to risk spoiling the film, ill stop now but the ending is heartbreaking and then heartwarming (pixar?). the moral is that everyone is free to act on their free will and that preconceived notions (towards robots ?) end badly.
i didnt hate coraline by any means but im definetely disappointed but i legimately did love the iron giant